Explain the relationship between deviations from standard cell conditions and changes in the cell potential.
In a real system under nonstandard conditions, the cell potential varies with the concentrations of the active species. The cell potential is a driving force toward equilibrium: the farther the reaction is from equilibrium, the greater the magnitude of the cell potential.
EK 9.10.A.2 issues a warning: equilibrium arguments such as Le Châtelier's principle do not apply to electrochemical systems, because the systems are not at equilibrium. Reason with Q and K, or with the Nernst equation — not with "the shift".
EK 9.10.A.3 gives the full logic:
Concentration cells are the extreme case: both half-cells contain the same species, so E° = 0. The cell still runs, driven purely by the concentration difference. The direction of electron flow is determined by considering which direction moves the system toward equilibrium — the dilute half-cell is the anode, since oxidation there increases its concentration.
EK 9.10.A.4 is explicit about how this is assessed: algorithmic calculations using the Nernst equation are insufficient to demonstrate understanding. Students should qualitatively understand the effects of concentration on cell potential and use conceptual reasoning, including qualitative use of:
E = E° − (RT/nF) ln Q
Read the equation structurally: larger Q makes the subtracted term larger, so E falls below E°. Smaller Q makes it negative, so E rises above E°.
For the cell Zn(s) | Zn²⁺ ‖ Cu²⁺ | Cu(s), E°_cell = +1.10 V. Predict whether Ecell is greater than, less than, or equal to 1.10 V when (a) [Cu²⁺] is increased to 2.0 M with [Zn²⁺] at 1.0 M, (b) [Zn²⁺] is increased to 2.0 M with [Cu²⁺] at 1.0 M, and (c) the cell has been running for a long time.
The reaction: Zn(s) + Cu²⁺(aq) → Zn²⁺(aq) + Cu(s), so Q = [Zn²⁺]/[Cu²⁺]. (Solids are excluded.)
(a) Increasing [Cu²⁺] to 2.0 M.
Q = 1.0/2.0 = 0.50, which is less than 1.
In E = E° − (RT/nF) ln Q, a Q below 1 makes ln Q negative, so the subtracted term is negative and E > 1.10 V.
Conceptually: raising the reactant concentration moves the system further from equilibrium, and cell potential measures distance from equilibrium.
(b) Increasing [Zn²⁺] to 2.0 M.
Q = 2.0/1.0 = 2.0, which is greater than 1.
ln Q is now positive, so a positive quantity is subtracted and E < 1.10 V. More product means closer to equilibrium and a smaller driving force.
(c) After running a long time. As the cell operates, Zn is oxidized (raising [Zn²⁺]) and Cu²⁺ is reduced (lowering [Cu²⁺]), so Q climbs steadily. E therefore falls continuously and reaches zero when Q = K — the cell is at equilibrium and the battery is dead. Note that plenty of zinc and copper remain; what has been exhausted is the driving force, not the material.